FIRST REACTIONS ON TRIER'S MELANCHOLIA FROM SCREENDAILY

By Mike Goodridge / SCREENDAILY

18-05-2011

 

Although at one point in the film I was hating it, by the end I was entirely under its spell. Von Trier is serious, meditative in Melancholia. It´s certainly his most serious film in a while and you don´t get the

sense that he is manipulating or mocking the audience as he usually

does. It feels like he is passionate about his material here, possibly

because it´s a movie about depression and Von Trier has said openly that

he battles depression himself.

Divided

into two halves - one following Kirtsen Dunst through her wedding

reception, one following her sister Charlotte Gainsbourg as it dawns on

her that a rogue planet (called, you guessed it, Melancholia) is going

to collide with Earth - the film is a meditative, haunting and

ultimately devastating work that fearlessly reflects on the meaning of

it all.
 
Key to its success is a stunning performance by Dunst

(who has also talked publicly about suffering from depression), a

beautiful, successful young advertising executive who is chronically

depressed and senses the impending end of the world. Dunst´s face says

everything (which is a good job since some of the dialogue is awful), as

she veers from extreme happiness to despair and finally a quiet

strength in the face of inevitable nothingness. Dunst´s star is reborn

here and she is an immediate contender for the best actress award at

Cannes.
 
Von Trier also reminds us what a visual master he is,

and the use of beautiful imagery here to illustrate his theme from the

gorgeous prologue (accompanied by music from Wagner´s Tristan And Isolde) to the final astonishing moments are even more effective than Terrence Malick´s The Tree Of Life.
 
Memorable

and hilarious in a small role is Udo Kier as the wedding planner who

refuses to look at Dunst after she disturbs the order of the day,

shielding his eyes every time she comes into his line of vision.